Tuesday, October 30, 2007

Are you not entertained?

The Patriots once again dismantle, destroy and embarrass another NFL opponent this past Sunday. I got a chance to attend the game and bit, making my decision based on many Foxboro games in the past that were very exciting but not this years' Pats edition. The games are often over by halftime and they haven't won by less than 14 points. This sort of thrashing is akin to Maximus in the provincial gladiator circuit slashing throats and bashing skulls with no difficulty, winning every bout with few moments of real drama and even less fanfare. Disgusted with the carnage but nonetheless elated by it, Maximus goads the crowd, "Are you not entertained?" To which the crowd roars in response, their undefeatable idol so talented, the actual match was not worth a cheer; but in his victory comes their adulation.

Another note about the Patriots victory over the Redskins was the issue of running-up the score. These are not amateur or student athletes. We are dealing with professional athletes that get paid in monopoly money salaries. There really isn't any room for sentiment with final scores. Us laymen like to compare what we see on the field on friday night and saturday afternoons with what happens on sunday but its just not comparable. We are trying to make a lesson of moral relevance with a level of competition that we cannot compare. From the opinion of this weak pushover, however, it still smacks of the ol' runnin' it up. But once you lose the killer instinct on the field, you may not be able to turn it back on. The team is tuned so well right now, only a moron would tell his team to "ease up" on these other sports professionals. They may need leniency for their poor self-esteems. Actually it may teach them some humility, a quality definitely lacking among pro-athletes.

While we're on the topic of running up scores, it’s very convenient for other teams to be begging for mercy after what happened after this season’s week one incident. Spygate anyone? That has been long forgotten after the Patriots wiped the floor with the favored Chargers in a game that has rematch later this year spray painted all over. I can’t remember one team, or player speaking in favor of the Patriots, in effect nobody came to their defense to respect what they had accomplished in years past, instead believing or wishing in a muckraking, substance-light conspiracy theory of cheating. The “cheating” did happen, but the extent to which it was blamed for past victories was way out of proportion. NFL officials, coaches, players, and fans had just let the lion out of the cage, giving feast to the ravished Patriots who always use misplaced quotes and the disrespect card to fuel their fire. Well, the NFL succeeded in giving them fuel for a bonfire. And now those same coaches, players and fans want to pull the reigns in. Well, I say blow ‘em away Bill. No mercy. Do people remember what teams did to the old hapless Patriots? Was there any quarter given? I don’t think so. This is the NFL, not pop-warner.

Tuesday, October 23, 2007

Boston Tourism Rating Falls

Boston, although officially still recognized as a 6 point (of 12) World City by GaWC , but as a destination we are losing ground to other destinations in North America. Once rated up there with New York and San Francisco as prime vacation destinations, Condé Nast traveler and Travel+ Leisure have both recently relegated Boston to the obscurity of a minor city.

Let’s be fair to admit that Boston’s cultural attractions do not bow to any in America. With world class museums, heritage sights, and universities, Boston will always remain the historical destination. With a Market town patchwork of streets and alleys, Boston is one of the few American cities that is authentically pedestrian. Restaurants abound in all downtown neighborhoods and with the ocean on its doorfront, seafood reigns. Sports in Boston also reign. Fenway Park is the oldest Major league stadium in the nation and is itself a museum. With gorgeous parks, an urban river and the harbor, the city is no doubt a beautiful place.

But the ratings have dropped? That’s no surprise. What would Americans these days see in Boston? Travel and Leisure kowtows to luxurious details, mostly in hotel interiors and fashionable dining experiences, but does not pay any homage to the culturally significant. In their eyes, the hotel equals the experience. For any sensible tourist or sightseer, the only worthwhile time in a hotel is for sleeping. True, in a world always spinning, many tourists seek rest and relaxation above experience, and Boston is not for them. Boston must be met with a pair of walking shoes, a healthy appetite for hearty seafood and thirst for Sam Adams or Harpoon.

Boston is not a fashionable place, and most of its worthwhile bars are miles away from downtown. Boston is not a place where high-brand nightlife is measured nor should it. It is safe to say that Boston’s people are not the most attractive. Boston is not Vegas and should never pretend to be, nor try to compete. Just the same, Vegas is not Boston. Measuring a city’s cultural value has been degraded in recent years with a culture obsessed with the trivial and indulgent on throw-away experiences. A city with a diverse historical context, steeped in traditions (gradually being washed into the American mainstream), and its automobile-unfriendly nature makes Boston not immediately accessible for most people. It’s a more sumptuous locale, comparing organic food to McDonalds. People looking for the instant gratification of tasty condiments should seek alternate destinations.

Another complaint is from expensive hotel costs and unfriendliness. With a limited area of downtown, it is no doubt Boston’s downtown hotels; in Copley Square, Financial District, or in Cambridgeside, are expensive. But you will find this in every worthwhile city. Take a look at an average Manhattan hotel. New York is not only known for being expensive, but its people are some of the most insulting rude and obnoxious outside of Paris. In my experience, however, the people in Boston who are most revolting to outsiders are usually outsiders themselves, living and working in Boston for the experience. Once they ingratiate themselves with the subway and their immediate neighborhood, they wear these on their sleeves and are automatically angered when they are inconvenienced by tourists’ directions or slowing down to admire the buildings they are living in. These people are snobbish to locals and worse to tourists, and are mostly responsible for local neighborhoods losing their cultural identities. These people must be ignored. (But unfortunately it is the transplants that continually bring money into Boston and keep the city’s economy healthy.)

The numbers of tourists that continually flock to Boston each spring, summer and fall are a testament that Boston still can hang with other hyped tourist traps. Boston sure has some of the worst tourist traps in the country; the Fanueil Hall marketplace is perhaps the worst of all, but it remains one of few. Sure Boston’s nightclub scene suffers, but that will never (hopefully) be the appeal of the nighttime entertainment in Boston where our drinks are served in pubs. I still can’t believe that attractiveness of the cities inhabitants is even rated. Point ceded. Boston is not LA, Vegas or Miami. There are more hot chicks in those cities. Travel + Leisure once again missed the boat. When is that magazine going to float?

http://www.boston.com/travel/boston/articles/2007/10/22/losing_stature/

Monday, October 22, 2007

Halloween Party Cancelled!

Although I am disappointed because my costumes have been unanimously been voted "top chach" three years in a row, the cancellation of the halloween party can be viewed through an alternative lens and may not appear so bad after all. A) The host will not be ostracized by his condo neighbors for staging such an elaborate and riotous affair. B) There is a chance, albeit small, that less alcohol is consumed this coming weekend, which, judging by testaments of productivity, would be a good thing for our employers. C) We will be able to cheer wildly for the Red Sox in World Series game 3 without tripping over our ridiculously silly costumes. D) If there is no suitable replacement event, I will not have the anxiety that accompanies all hyped one-night events, especially costume events (new years, halloween etc), over whether it will live up to its billing or not.

Tuesday, October 16, 2007

The Mirror

When you are young and adventurous there is always a yearning to leave the safety of your comfortable environment and seek out the challenge of the unknown, a brand new adventure. As many cultures embrace this adventure time, in fact we have an institution that promotes "going away". Just as the aborigines have the walkabout, where a young man leaves his tribe as a rite of passage into adulthood and the Amish have rumspringa, a period where a young man or woman leaves the sect to decide whether the amish ways are right for him or her on an individual basis; Americans use college to this same endeavor. Other primates also employ this type of behavior as a method to maintain gene flow. Baboon males will leave one troop to join another so as to limit incest.

I have never studied abroad and experienced another culture and country intimately, and in the back of my mind I would like to move for a year or so to another place far away to experience how the canooks, kiwis or aussies live and work. It would be a completely educational experience with little or no time devoted to fun and games, but in the end I would be the better for it. It would give me time to make reasonable decisions about what I want to do with the rest of my life and at the same time, extinguish the unsettled travel pilot flame. When it was done I could head back into Americareer with a better feeling in my stomach for settling down with a better grasp on what I want to do with the rest of my life. When I told my dad of my plan he answered, "You still have to look in the mirror every morning."

Is it that I want to get out of the dump I have made for myself here, jump from my grave I have been digging for myself or could it be that I want to gain new experiences without trying to remove myself from this one. Can we yearn to experience new places while not trying to escape the current ones? After all why would you want to leave if all was well? As I attempt to come to terms with these opposing rationales, I see more often than not that both are mutually exclusive; accepting one with truth convicts the other's reasonable plausibility.

Sunday, September 30, 2007

Relieving Boston's Traffic Woes: The Urban Ring

[As usual Americans treat the symptoms not the problem; part 1 of 2]

The Aftermath of the Big Dig

It is true that Boston will soon experience the benefits of a wide swath of a plush new green space ribbon that cuts a swath down the center of the financial district and connects the North End with the downtown for the first time since the JFK expressway was elevated in the 1950s. It was not the first time that a decades-old elevated transportation system was torn down. The elevated rail service that ran over Atlantic Avenue from 1903 to 1937 cut the North End from the docks. Another elevated service cut Boston's downtown in two. Perhaps the Big Dig represents the transportation improvements for this half of the 21st century. Let’s hope not.

There are numerous examples of cities that could create relatively inexpensive light rail along EXISTING rail and automobile routes with little difficulty1. Boston has North America’s oldest existing subway line but hasn’t added a new rail line since the 1970s. Traffic keeps piling up on the highways and yet the existing T’s operations are too expensive. When do road improvements and repairs become too expensive? When does the waste of an hour during morning and evening commute become too costly? It is very clear that the existing infrastructure is over capacity. That is understated. The existing infrastructure is obsolete; even after the Big Dig.

England’s City

Boston’s streets are one of the few cities in America that do not follow a grid pattern. In the mode of an English Market town, Boston’s downtown streets form a patchwork of medieval streets that begin and end in one block. Traveling in the downtown posed no problem for those working and living within blocks of their destinations but for those going from one side to the other, there is no direct and quickest route. Subway routes alleviated some of this congestion. The 1950s elevated highway made Boston surpassable by Car.

Although the original plan never did take path, as I-95 was re-routed to travel along the existing Rt 128 “Scenic” Highway, and the I-695 inner-belt through Somerville, Cambridge and Brookline never got off the planning boards, the elevated highway that split the downtown gave commuters two options; venture into the downtown or completely around it.

Rt. 128

Today, all transit routes continue to go into the city as spokes on a wheel. This forces workers who work and live in opposite sides of the city to travel along Rt. 128. The Yankee Division Highway (named for the 26th Infantry Division which served in WWI and WWII) was built in the 1920s but was upgraded to handle traffic in subsequent years. In 1951, it became the first circumferential highway in the United States. In 1958, it was widened from 6 to 8 lanes. This influenced companies to take route on the highway route and business surged along 128. Unfortunately, traffic began to pile up from this added traffic and now the highway is over-capacity and clogged between the rush hours, especially near the major interchanges in the north and south of Boston.

While the Big Dig is already outdated and no substantial improvements are in sight for the existing highway network, (Try building an I-695 through Cambridge and Brookline now!) traffic can be alleviated on existing networks by improvements and enlargements of secondary routes. These secondary routes consist of limited access (and distance) highways, roads and rail.

The Future

Americans have always been ephemeral even when it comes to urban design. The concept of permanence, especially with regards to a city has only taken root in recent years. Years before the automobile, train tracks dotted across the Boston metro area, carrying people, goods and services to and from Boston with speed (relative to the day). When the power and appeal of the automobile crushed any alternative transportation choices, many cities destroyed existing rail lines and tore up plans for new track to spread concrete for the car. We are one of the lucky few cities in America that has track still existing and corridors that can be utilized to provide new secondary routes. There has been a suggestion(s) to eliminate roadways for pedestrian walkways, which will promote public transportation, but also create traffic nightmares. Pedestrian ways would benefit most after public transportation is upgraded.

While our public transit system should not be cherished for its inefficiencies, it should not be blamed for its inadequacy. Many people do not take the subway or commuter rail because it does not allow the passenger the freedom of destination as a car. One cannot get from points in Somerville or Malden without taking a train into Boston’s Park Street or Downtown Crossing stations before changing onto another train to go to Cambridge’s Harvard Square or Central Square stations. This is the case for every existing subway line. With the local exceptions of the Green line split in Kenmore Square (or Copley for the E line) and Red Line at UMASS-JFK, there is no link that unites all of the urban communities of Boston. This results in increased automobile traffic and unnecessary congestion in downtown stations. I have researched some different opportunities and have come up with the following plans.

The Urban Ring – 1st Strategy: Blue/Orange/Red/Green/Orange/Red

There is an easy and obvious solution. Unite the 1st tier communities (those adjacent to Boston) within the Rt 128 belt with two circumferential rapid transit/subway train service lines along existing and new service track that would connect East Boston and (in this order) Chelsea, Everett, Somerville, Cambridge and Allston with one line. Another line would start in Allston/Kenmore Square and utilize the existing Worcester-Boston commuter rail to connect Allston and Kenmore Square to the Prudential Center and then divert with a new tunnel underneath Massacusetts Avenue with underground stops at Tremont/Dartmouth Washington St./Franklin Square and New Market Square and ending at the existing Andrew Square Red Line. This would benefit communities traditionally thwarted by convenient public transportation, especially residents of Chelsea, Everett, Allston and the South End. With added transfer options, commuters from other outlying communities would be more enticed to park and ride to avoid the congestion on Rt. 128 and I-93/Rt. 3.

The Urban Ring – 2nd Strategy: The Parallel (I-95 Belt and Boston Metro)

Another strategy to reroute traffic along Rt.128 would be to use the existing corridor and lay rail directly along the path of Rt 128 and create a parallel track with stations in several communities that links commuter rail stations and rapid transit (T) stations with the hub (Downtown Boston) and the wheel (Rt.128 Railway). Several existing commuter rail stations would be modified and a few new stations would need to be built. North of Boston, the Parralel line could start with a brand new station in Danvers (along the existing junction of track) moving west to a new park and ride station in West Peabody where the interchange of I-95, Rt. 128 and Rt. 1 converge along existing track. The track runs through Lynnfield (added station) and then moves from existing track onto the Parralel high speed line. A new Reading/Wakefield park and ride stop at North Ave. interchange in Wakefield could eliminate both Reading and Wakefield commuter stops as a convenient midpoint and the Orange line could continue along its existing track and terminate at this point. Add a 3-stop busing service to both community centers to the new station during traffic periods to alleviate convenience/parking concerns.

Continuing west (southbound) along I-95/Rt. 128 is the I-93 interchange with a convenient station located in Woburn (Mishawum). A Burlington/Mall Stop could then be added with additional parking. [An offshoot of the Parralel could link Lowell with Burlington with stops in Chelmsford, Nutting Lake, and Sun Microsystems/Mitre.] The Parallel then turns south by the Hanscom Field/AFB (a future stop when the Airfield is enlarged to become Boston International?) and would stop at (the moved) Kendall Green/Brandeis Station between Weston and Waltham at the Rt. 20 Rotary. Additional parking would have to be built. Bus service to and from Brandeis would be provided by the school. The next logical station would be at the Weston station being constructed at the interchange of I-95/Rt.128 and the Mass Pike (I-90). This would be a hub and would consist of the Boston-Worcester Commuter Line and an extended Green line from the Riverside station. It would be a costly expansion through West Newton/Auburndale but would provide the key link to Rapid Transit stations with more flexibility.

Below the Mass Pike, The Parallel would add a station at Highland Ave., with another extension of the Green D Line’s track along existing track on Needham St. and ending with a Rapid Transit connection on the Newton/Needham Border. It would then run south and link with existing Dedham Corporate and Westwood’s Rt 128 Station and Amtrak connection. This would allow Amtrak riders, exiting at Rt. 128 to board Parallel trains to North and South shore destinations. The track would then jump highways from I-95 Southbound to I-95 Northbound and turn south to east. The next logical station would be the Fall River Expressway (Rt. 24) in the Blue Hills Reservation. The Parallel would end in the Five Corners on the border of Quincy, Braintree and Weymouth. The station would need a Red Line connection as well as commuter train access to the Middleborough/Plymouth and Greenbush lines.

The scope of the Parallel High speed transit line is grand. The potential benefits are enormous. Besides offering a dependable circumferential transportation option, it links numerous commuter and rapid transit (T) lines that could potentially re-route tens of thousands of commuters from inside and outside of Boston daily, provide economic revitalization to many bypassed communities and alleviate existing transportation networks drastically. Let Boston be an example of alternative transportation and stop the path of least resistance and most futility. Why do we pay such reverence to the car with needless and endless bouts in traffic, when an exciting and viable alternative could provide a world of benefits?


Enlarging the existing MBTA Light rail service (similar to Option 1 above)

Monday, September 24, 2007

The War on PBS – "A Necessary War"

I am hard-pressed to watch a moment of more emotional film than the original ending of last night’s first episode of “The War” on PBS. Ken Burns tied the desperate situation of our servicemen in the South Pacific to the release of Bing Crosby’s White Christmas in the winter of 1942. I can only imagine, but that song must have touched on their feelings of isolation on Guadalcanal being so far from their families and safety, and at the same time providing comfort and cheer with soothing lyrics reminding them of the joys of their past holidays. The hot, humid climates of the battlefield and the uncertain outcome of their personal situation must have been daunting; knowing what lay ahead was hold-at-all-costs, death or brutal captivity. And yet the song tied to them to their hometowns, a stake of hope in a place of no-end-in-sight.

Part 1 (of 7)

Wednesday, September 19, 2007

Exoneration for Belichick?

If there was a better way to answer the nay-sayers and those with ring-envy than the trouncing of the San Diego Chargers with a national television audience in tow, then I have lost touch. Generally considered a top echelon team, the Chargers were systematically picked apart by the larger predator, the blood-thirsty Patriots. They proved to everyone that this camera-gate incident had little or no actual effect on game play and the Patriots had accomplished their dynasty on teamwork, discipline and talent.

The media coverage on this story should disappear. Or so I thought. On the news and coverage of the Monday night ESPN telecast, again we have the experts, former players and coaches, like stone pillars on the moral high ground casting down their sanctimonious judgments to the people. What a bunch of long-winded morons. Everybody wants to look tough on crime, but it seems no one has been troubled to really understand what advantage filming opposing signals offers. If everyone in the NFL steals signals, why is Belichick chastised for doing it too?

The analogies are ridiculous. A comparison to Bonds, the biggest cheater today is over the top. The “experts” did not even take the time to explain to the fans what Belichick did that was so vile and why it was against the rules. If they had, fans would not nearly be as upset and perplexed by this scandal. It is true that Belichick broke NFL rules…but… should stealing a candy bar cost one’s hand as punishment? Let’s call a spade a spade and see the reaction to the scandal not as a proper punishment reprimand but blatant acrimony.

Friday, September 14, 2007

League comes down soft on Belichick?

In the wake of cameragate, Goodell has levied his punishments and the football audience cries foul…still. What would suffice, jail time? Yes, it was cheating. Yes, Belichick, dubbed Beli-cheat, deserves punishment. He was fined a personal $500,000! While that may not be debilitating for a millionaire football coach, it is still the maximum fine that can be given by the NFL. The loss of a draft selection from next year’s draft, likely the team’s #1 selection, would potentially cripple any team save the Patriots; they have another #1 pick from the hands of San Francisco.

And this is where the outrage starts to make sense. People are not looking to make the punishment fit the crime. Instead, there is an assessment on the Patriots’ success and a determination of what punishment will most likely affect that success. If most other teams were caught cheating in the same manner, there would likely be a smaller fine and be docked lower draft selections. Then it would be case closed, who cares. With the Patriots, and especially Belichick, there is a pervasive sense that the punishment is being determined by who is guilty, instead of what they are guilty of. It seems how to make the Patriots suffer the most is more important than having a just and universal punishment. And didn’t Mangini hire that camera guy in the first place? It's simply hard to believe that stealing signals is not happening anywhere else.

Thursday, September 13, 2007

Cameragate and “Belichick the Cheater”

As an ardent Pats fan, it’s a little tough to be thoroughly unbiased about an issue that has drawn out even the most hidden resentment towards the Patriots. Anything I say to defend my team will be seen as it comes through the fan’s window pane. Of course you can expect LaDainian Tomlinson to put his two cents in. The upcoming game has a lot to say about the outcome of his statements. If the sans-camera Patriots defeat the Chargers at home on Sunday, they will appear to be partially vindicated, however, if they lose, I fear it will bring on more criticism of past victories and even taint the super bowl victories? Criticism has also come from the Steelers camp, another enclave of Patriots’ bitterness. It comes in from Carson Palmer, who’s Bengals are dealing with their own run-ins with commissioner Goodell and the player suspensions that plague their criminal players. Palmer wants the NFL to throw the book at Belichick as hard as it has befallen his Bengals. And finally, it pours in from those people who have had to listen to 5+ years of media fed propaganda about how classy Kraft’s organization is.

I have written about the Pats here and indirectly about their class as an organization and I have to admit, there is no way I can defend Belichick’s class here. His job has always been to win games and not to be some sort of messiah for moral fortitude on and off the football field. Somehow being a proponent of team play has made media and fan alike identify Belichick with the qualities of being a team player, which he is not. Belichick’s goal for team first, individual second derives from simple math. It takes eleven men on both sides of the ball for a team to be most successful. While the Patriots are comprised of many classy team players, our coach may not be one. Nonetheless, he is a supreme head football coach, and the methods by which signal calls by opposing teams are deciphered are just another gun in his tremendous arsenal. While videotaping the defensive play signals from the sideline may seem excessive (and illegal), there is a reason that the opposing team gives signals…so the other team won’t understand. Every team has their people whose job is to steal signals. That is why offensive coordinators cover their mouths when speaking. Any edge, any advantage where the endgame is victory. But illegal is illegal and victory by cheating is so cheap and it tears Belichick down from the “team first” high horse back to the pit with the rest of us…all too willing to sacrifice values for a cheap win.

The puzzling part is why he did it in the first place? What advantage did filming an opposing team’s signals give in that game. I have heard logic that by the second half, after analysis in the film room during half-time, the signals for the defense could be cracked and the offense could plan on the go but previous games don’t support that argument. The Patriots were clueless in the second half of the Pats-Colts AFC championship game last year. (By the way, nothing has come from the Colts about this incident) While Belichick is hailed as a king of the second-half adjustment, I can’t imagine how videotaping signals can be more advantageous during a game, then just having a guy watch the signals and mark them to each play. A set of binoculars and a pen is the old-fashioned way and works as well as videotape. Probably faster too. I can’t wait until this is all forgotten, the Pats get their (light) punishment and we can move on and try to win another super bowl, tainted or otherwise.